I encourage you to work on short fiction, simply because you can learn and improve more quickly when writing short pieces. If you write something short, then we can look at it as a whole, and figure out whether it works or not, which elements are weak and which are strong, and how the weak elements could be improved.
In critiquing a chapter of a novel, we can figure out some of those issues, but since the work is not complete, some problems might be difficult to detect until the entire book is done (for example, the chapter might be well written and interesting, but it may be unnecessary to the book).
That said, though, an important aspect of Your Personal Odyssey is that you can shape the program to fit your needs and interests. And I believe that the most important thing is that you work on projects that you’re passionate about. Your progress may be a little slower and the issues you’re dealing with may be more complex, but we’ve had great success at Your Personal Odyssey, helping novelists who have gone on to sell their novels.
In the lectures, we cover all the major elements of fiction writing, and specifically discuss the challenges those elements present in f/sf/h fiction. We also discuss how these issues differ in short fiction and long fiction. So different aspects of novel writing are covered.
In one-on-one mentoring sessions, I try to help students writing novels to apply those various concepts to their work. We also often create individual assignments that help the student strengthen various aspects of the novel, as through writing a novel outline, charting character arcs, worldbuilding, and developing voices for different viewpoints.
I also sometimes point students to special readings or exercises to help them with specific points. These may involve issues particular to longer fiction. As you submit more chapters for critiquing, I’ll get a better sense of how those chapters fit into your outline, and a better idea of the strengths and weaknesses of the overall story structure, which we’ll discuss.
It can be extremely difficult to get some emotional distance from a novel and see it objectively, as a reader sees it; that’s one of the important things Your Personal Odyssey provides. Students also see much more clearly the weaknesses in their novels, and they learn the skills to tackle those and make major improvements.